Main Content

188 Judith’s Fancy CO, St. Croix, 00820 (MLS# 26-332)

188 Judith's Fancy CO, St. Croix, 00820

$825,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 3 Baths: 2 Square Footage: 2,400 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 33,106 Status: Active
Current Price: $825,000 List Date: 2/16/2026 Last Modified: 2/18/2026

Description

Set on a sloped knoll in a tranquil and prestigious enclave with breathtaking views of Buck Island is 188 Judith's Fancy. A meticulously maintained three-bedroom, two-bathroom home with expansive outdoor space, 2 car garage and mature landscaping. The home was built to suit a true entertainer both indoors and outdoors. Two patios totalling just under 1,500 square feet with sea views that spill onto a manicured lawn with box top but trees that provide a lovely shady area for picnicking or play. Residents will enter the home through the two-car garage through the large wood paneled Family/Entertainment Room. CONTINUED

Supplements: This room has many highlights: a full bar, breakfast nook, sliders out to the patio, a riser to elevate TV/Stereo equipment and also ample room for a movie theatre screen and seating, and a boxed area with a stone wall with three skylights to nourish the plants. The full bar is 8 feet long, has built in shelving and a mini fridge. One step up takes you to the open floor plan living/dining/kitchen areas. The living room is also wood panelled and has beautiful arched and lighted shelves on both sides of the archway connecting the Family/Entertainment Room. The 13-foot ceiling in the living room brings the airiness of the sea and views inside and fills the space with calm. The kitchen features a built-in bottle rack above the breakfast bar. The kitchen cabinets have pullout drawers in most of the cabinets to make for neat storage and easy access. The eastern exposure of the home is all windows allowing for those seated at the dining table to gaze at the water while enjoying the sea breezes. The primary and second bedroom both have east facing windows that have Buck Island views. Both have ensuite bathrooms, large closets with built in custom closet organization and mini split AC's. The third bedroom smaller has a walk-in closet that could be converted to a bathroom. The garage with two automatic door openers houses 3 separate rooms: one for laundry, storage and generator. Other points of polish: are the stone wall that encloses the back patio; large paved driveway that allows for multigenerational inhabitants to park easily while allowing egress to the cars in the garage; pavers that lead the from the driveway to the formal entrance on the patio; concrete garden boxes for the mature shrubbery and hedges; elegantly tiled WAPA meter base; to name a few. See the Documents section for a list up updates the Seller has made to the home.

More Information MLS# 26-332

Location/Area

Plot/Unit Number: 188 Island: St. Croix Quarter: Company

General Property Description

Realtor.COM Type: Residential - Single Family Number of Bedrooms - Main House: 3 Number of Bedrooms - Accessory building: 0 Total Bathrooms: 2 Taxes: 802.63 Furnished: Yes Tax Year: 2026 Lot Acres: 0.76 Water Front: No Pool: No Zoning: R-1 Stamp Tax: Paid by Buyer Approx Interior SqFt-Accessory Unit Total: 0 Approx Exterior SqFt-Accessory Unit Total: 0 Approx Total Main House: 4755 Approx Total Property SqFt: 2400 Total Bedrooms: 3 Sub Type: Residential - Single Year Built: 1968

Contract Information

Concessions: No List Price: $825,000 Current Price: $825,000 Begin Date: 2026-02-16

Miscellaneous

PWD#: 753-P

Amenities

Filtration System: 1 Gallery: 1 Garage: 1 Generator: Diesel Generator/Size: 6.5 Patio: 1

View

Buck Island: 1 Neighborhood: 1 Sea: 1

Appliance

Air Conditioning: Split Dishwasher: 1 Dryer: 1 Fans: Yes Microwave: 1 Range: 1 Refrigerator: 1 Washer: 1

Construction

Concrete Block: 1 Mixed: 1

Flooring

Tile: 1

Exterior

Storm Shutters: Panels

Listing Info

Sign: Yes

Road

Paved: 1

Security

Camera: 1

Roof

Fluid Applied: 1

Water Source

Cistern: 1

Main House

Approx Interior SqFt - Main House: 2801 Approx Exterior SqFt - Main House: 1954

Fees

Association Fee: 1 Association Fee Amount: 1300 Association Fee Frequency: Annually

LocationArea

Estate: Judith's Fancy CO Postal Code: 00820 Geo Lat: 17.774371 Geo Lon: -64.748665 Directions: Enter the development of Judith's Fancy through the Guard Gate - Listing Agent will announce your visit to the Guard. Turn left on Caribe Road. Turn right on Dove Lane. The house is the first house on the right with globe lights on driveway pillars.

Status Change Info

Status: Active

Property Features

View: Buck Island; Neighborhood; Sea Amenities: Filtration System; Gallery; Garage; Patio Flooring: Tile Construction: Concrete Block; Mixed Roof: Fluid Applied Water Source: Cistern Road: Paved Security: Camera Fees: Association Fee
Listing Office: Calabash Real Estate
Office Phone: 340-718-5285
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Skip to content